will challenge

Successful Will Challenge Yields Blended Cost Award

• • 0 Comments

The Applicant (the Deceased’s son) brought an application seeking to invalidate the Deceased’s 2023 Will, submit the Deceased’s 2022 Will for probate, and seek the return of the Deceased’s $95,000 gift to his nephew. The Deceased executed wills on March 16, 2022 and November 22, 2023. In his 2022 Will, the Applicant is named as the estate trustee, the Deceased gifts his home and its contents to the Applicant and names the….

Successful Will Challenge Yields Blended Cost Award Continue Reading »

Estate Litigation, Wills

Estate Trustees Ordered to Not Use Estate Assets to Fund Litigation

• • 0 Comments

In a recent will challenge case, the court ruled that the estate trustees during litigation could not access estate funds to pay their legal fees. The testator (“Hans”) and his late wife (“Colleen”) married in 1987.  Together, they had 7 children from their previous marriages. In 2005, Hans and Colleen made wills in which their respective estate would be gifted to the surviving spouse and upon the death of the….

Estate Trustees Ordered to Not Use Estate Assets to Fund Litigation Continue Reading »

Estate Litigation, Wills

The Importance of Independent Witnesses in a Will Challenge

• • 0 Comments

Di Nunzio vs Di Nunzio reminds us of the standard of evidence required in a will challenge. The testator made a new will in 2017 (the “2017 Will’).  The 2017 Will was made while the testator was in palliative care and she retained a new lawyer to assist her to make the will. In the 2017 Will, she appoints her daughter Teresa (her primary caregiver) as her estate trustee and….

The Importance of Independent Witnesses in a Will Challenge Continue Reading »

Wills

Meeting the Will Challenge Threshold

• • 1 Comment

Today’s blog was written by Christina Papadopoulos, an articling student with de VRIES LITIGATION LLP. What is the minimum level of evidence to be met before a court allows a will challenge to proceed? The recent Ontario Superior Court of Justice decision in Naismith v. Clarke, 2019 ONSC 5280 (“Naismith”) sets out a useful overview for the circumstances under which a court may allow a will challenge to move forward…..

Meeting the Will Challenge Threshold Continue Reading »

Contested wills, Estate Litigation, Testamentary Capacity, Wills

An Intriguing Will Challenge

• • 0 Comments

In Koster v. Koster, the Deceased’s nieces and nephews challenged his last will on the grounds of undue influence. There is nothing unusual about a will challenge in these circumstances, the Deceased was a very wealthy man who changed his will in the twilight years of his life. What was unusual is that the nieces and nephews benefit under the Deceased’s last will that they are challenging. If they are….

An Intriguing Will Challenge Continue Reading »

Estate Litigation, Undue influence

Videographers Beware

•

Occasionally, those hoping to demonstrate the capacity of a testator will film a video of the testator purporting to show that they were cognitively intact or that the will was a reflection of their independent and capable wishes. Unfortunately, the naïve interviewer makes the mistake of confusing the preservation of social graces for intact cognition and considers passive acquiescence as evidence of independence of mind. Clinicians understand, or should understand, that one….

Videographers Beware Continue Reading »

Capacity Law, Contested wills, Estate Litigation, Family Conflict, Undue influence
Scroll to Top